News
21 November, 2026
Amalgamation is still ‘just a proposal’
The Catholic Diocese of Wollongong has moved to reassure the St Michael’s community that a proposed amalgamation with St Thomas Aquinas is not ‘on pause’.
The Catholic Diocese of Wollongong has moved to reassure the St Michael’s community that a proposed amalgamation with St Thomas Aquinas is not ‘on pause’.
Chancellor of the Diocese, Matt Baxter – who is managing the consultation process relating to the proposed amalgamation of the two Catholic primary schools – wrote to parents this week to confirm the original decision had been revoked by Bishop Mascord.
He said it had returned to being a parish proposal for the Bishop’s consideration and the Diocese’s focus was now on providing members of both school communities with the necessary time, information and opportunity to provide feedback.
In his letter, Mr Baxter acknowledged the “sense of shock” that many people felt in response to the original decision and the “disappointment you felt in not having had a chance to have your say before an announcement was made”.
He also acknowledged that “aspects of the consultation process may not have been clearly communicated to everyone”.
“While it’s not possible to go back in time, our focus now is on making sure everyone has the chance to be heard in a consultation process that is respectful, transparent and genuinely focused on helping Bishop Brian consider the parish’s proposal in light of the perspectives of parents, staff, and parishioners,” Mr Baxter said.
As reported by The Southern Wire, the Bishop announced last month St Michael’s Catholic Primary School in Mittagong and St Thomas Aquinas Catholic Primary School would be amalgamated from the commencement of the 2029 school year to form the Corpus Christi Catholic Primary School.
The new school was to be based in Bowral with future options for the Mittagong site to be investigated.
However, the Bishop subsequently revoked his decision following an outcry from angry parents and announced the start of a month-long consultation process.
While parents have welcomed the Bishop’s decision, they have pointed out that the consultation process will run for 25 days (rather than 30 days) and say the compressed timeframe, a cancelled parent meeting and lack of clear financial and enrolment data have placed children, teachers, and households under “acute emotional strain”.
“Right now, our community is living under a cloud of constant anxiety and distress as a result of our beloved school being at risk of closure,” St Michael’s parent Katrina Virtue said this week.
“Parents and teaching staff are losing sleep, children are picking up on the fear of the unknown and a school community that once thrived in peace is gripped by uncertainty.
“Families across our community are already grappling with the increasing pressures of everyday life - facing rising financial strains and the heavy realities of the current cost-of-living crisis.
“Where is the pastoral care for the children, families, and staff of St Michael’s at this time?” she asked.
Last Friday (November 13) the Diocese released a 13-page proposal document alongside a letter cancelling the planned November 18 community meeting as “no longer required”.
Parents are concerned that while the proposal outlines speculative future uses for the Mittagong site, it contains no enrolment projections, no comparative financial figures and no feasibility studies, while deferring transport and traffic planning until 2027-28 - after a final closure decision is made.
Speaking on ABC Illawarra Breakfast, petition organiser Kathryn Dovey reinforced that parents respect the Church’s authority and property ownership, but are asking for “genuine pastoral listening and empirical evidence” before any irreversible decision is made.
“We respect the Church’s authority and property ownership, but we ask that it respects the families, children, and communities affected by its decisions,” Ms Dovey said.
“This is not about who owns the buildings - it is about ensuring the people most affected by a permanent closure are genuinely heard and given the facts, before that decision is made.”
The ‘speculative’ future uses for the Mittagong site outlined in the document include independent seniors living, adult and disability care and allied health and community space.
It states that ‘repurposing’ the site would enable the parish to “make a much more meaningful contribution to meeting the needs of the vulnerable, isolated and aged across the region”.
The Save St Michael’s Mittagong group said parent-conducted surveys across both schools in early November confirmed overwhelming support for retaining both campuses, with 95 per cent of St Michael’s respondents (58 of 61) and 84 per cent of St Thomas Aquinas Bowral respondents (31 of 37) preferring two separate school sites.
More than 3,700 community members have signed the GetUp petition to keep St Michael’s open.
It said Diocesan data confirmed resilient demand at St Michael’s, with 186 students enrolled in 2026, 27 Kindergarten starters confirmed for 2027 and an active waitlist of 18 children, alongside ACARA recognition on the 2025 Schools Making a Difference list (+26 NAPLAN points above national averages).
ABS Census records and Wingecarribee Shire Council forecasts confirm that Mittagong and the northern villages hold the highest growth of young families in the district - projecting 1,644 new dwellings and up to 590 new primary students by 2041, while Mittagong Public School is already at full capacity with 536 students.
Parent advocates have also said that under Catholic Canon Law, the faithful have the right and duty to make their views known to their pastors and a parish priest’s pastoral care extends to all people living within parish boundaries - including non-Catholic and wider-community families who embrace St Michael’s teaching quality and community life.
The group has made five ‘practical’ requests before consultation closes:
Extend the November 30 deadline and provide a genuine 30-day window for comment;
Release the underlying business plan, case study and financial figures;
Include a genuine option to retain both schools;
Hold an open meeting for all families, and
Verify every submission and clarify 2028 enrolments.
In his letter, Mr Baxter said P&F office holders from St Michael’s and St Thomas Aquinas had been invited to participate in a roundtable discussion to present the views of the parent bodies “in a more conversational format”.
He said this decision had been made “due to the number of families and the difficulty of achieving a meaningful discussion with potentially hundreds of people in the room”.
Every parent would still have the opportunity to provide feedback through the consultation form made available at the end of October.
He said the roundtable would be facilitated by an independent facilitator and would provide P&F representatives with the opportunity to share feedback, ask questions and raise concerns.
Mr Baxter said a ‘consultation results document’ would be prepared at the conclusion of the consultation process and provided to parents, staff, and parishioners.
“If it becomes clear at this point that more input is required, the opportunity for further consultation will be provided.
He said the Bishop’s final decision would be accompanied by a detailed explanation of how consultation feedback was considered and how it influenced the outcome.
Read More: Bowral, Mittagong, Southern Highlands