Advertisement

News

17 November, 2026

‘Unfair’ refusals keeping Justin and his fiancée apart

Goulburn’s Justin Skinner talks to his Thai wife every day over the phone. But it’s not the same as talking to her face to face – and he says the Federal Government is to blame.

By Stuart Carless

Goulburn residents Justin Skinner says ‘unfair’ decisions by the Department of Home Affairs are keeping him and his fiancée apart.
Goulburn residents Justin Skinner says ‘unfair’ decisions by the Department of Home Affairs are keeping him and his fiancée apart.
Advertisement

Goulburn’s Justin Skinner talks to his Thai wife every day over the phone.

But it’s not the same as talking to her face to face – and he says the Federal Government is to blame.

Wannipa Baosongsri (Ning) has had her application for a visitor visa refused four times since September 2025.

The last two of those refusals came after the couple lodged a Prospective Marriage visa (PMV) application in January 2026.

The latest refusal – in October – came one month after they lodged a priority processing request on the PMV.

The repeated refusals are making it virtually impossible for them to plan their wedding and their future lives together in Australia.

Ning has never even been to Australia or visited the city which she will eventually call home.

“We just want to be together,” Mr Skinner told The Southern Wire.

He says the repeated refusals are unfair and are having a human, practical and financial impact that the Department of Home Affairs is failing to take into account.

He has reached out to his local MP, Member for Eden-Monaro Kirsty McBain, for assistance – without success – and says he has hit a brick wall.

Mr Skinner says the refusals are particularly frustrating given the Minister for Home Affairs Tony Burke gave an address at the National Press Club in September saying the Federal Government would make it easier for spouses to visit.

Mr Burke told the Press Club that changes to legislation would mean “that while someone is waiting for a spouse visa to come through, their partner will be able to visit on a regular basis”.

That has certainly not been his experience – or the experience of hundreds of other people who have taken to social media to share their stories and vent their frustrations.

“I understand that things take time and they have to do their crosses and checks and everything else,” Mr Skinner said.

“What I don’t understand is when they say they’re going to make it easier to visit and they don’t.”

The Department’s repeated decision to refuse a visitor visa is based largely on the belief that Ning does not have a strong incentive to return to Thailand at the end of her stay in Australia.

However, the reasons keep changing.

In September 2025 the Department questioned the strength of her “employment, financial and personal ties” to her home country with a Delegate of the Minister saying he was not satisfied “that the applicant genuinely intends to stay temporarily in Australia”.

In October 2025 – after Ning had started work as a cashier and stock controller – the Department said she didn’t have enough evidence of regular salary payments, despite those payments being made in cash.

“In Thailand, most people – a lot of people – get paid in cash, so trying to trace salaries from employment is quite difficult,” Mr Skinner said.

In February – after Ning had commenced studying to be a massage therapist – the Department raised concerns that she would be leaving her studies without approval.

In October – after Ning had again started working – the Department questioned her savings history and the nature of her employment.

“The employer’s ability to release the applicant from their current role for the purpose of their travel to Australia raises concerns that the applicant may not have ongoing employment with this employer after their visit to Australia,” a Delegate of the Minister concluded.

Mr Skinner described the Department’s reasoning as “ridiculous”.

He says Ning would never jeopardise the PMV by overstaying her visitor visa and, besides, speaks limited English.

“It just doesn’t make any sense.”

Equally as frustrating, Mr Skinner says, is the fact that the Federal Government is currently prioritising onshore visa applications (for those people already here in Australia) over offshore applications.

That means some people are coming here on a visitor visa and then applying for a bridging visa once they arrive.

Advertisement

Those people are being prioritised while Ning and others like her are being placed at the “back of the queue”.

“The other issue that I have is that another gentleman that I spoke to on social media had a partner from Indonesia who had no job at all and received the visitor visa.

“So where’s the consistency?

“I think it’s just based on the individual officer deciding what they want to at the time.

“It’s almost like a lottery.”

Mr Skinner currently travels to Thailand as often as he can – and when he can afford it – but the couple is forced to spend months apart between visits.

He says his overseas trips are also becoming increasingly difficult with Thai officials questioning the regularity of his visits and he fears that one day he will be turned around at the airport and sent home.

Mr Skinner and his fiancée are desperate for a solution given that it can take up to three years for a PMV to be processed, based on the Department’s own estimates.

That means Ning will need to keep applying for a visitor visa until January 2029 in the hope it will finally get approved.

Mr Skinner said the priority processing request was based on his medical condition.

He said his Type 1 diabetes could be “very erratic” and living alone was potentially dangerous.

He fears that one night he will sleep through the alarm that warns him when his glucose levels fall dangerously low.

“If I’m asleep and I don’t know what’s going on, Ning knows what to do,” Mr Skinner said.

“I’ll be brutally honest, when I’m alone, both of us hardly sleep but when we’re together we get a full night’s rest.

“I toss and turn and she does the same. All night we’re messaging because we’re worried about each other.”

Mr Skinner says he had already outlaid approximately $16,000 on visa applications, an agent to help guide them through the process and supporting information including police checks and medical checks.

To no avail.

It would cost him another $3727 simply to ask for a visa decision to be reviewed.

Mr Skinner now fears he will spend his 50th birthday in January alone.

“I won’t even be able to spend my 50th birthday with my fiancée.

“It will just be a phone call,” he said.

--------------

Subscribe to The Southern Wire Newsletter for free at the link below.

https://subscribe-forms.beehiiv.com/1986abc6-c89e-4781-9db2-cf35c9dd71e4

If you value independent local journalism across the Highlands, Tablelands and Wollondilly, please click the link below to support us to ensure we remain paywall free.

https://thesouthernwire.presspatron.com

 

Advertisement

Latest Articles

Advertisement

Most Popular

Advertisement