Advertisement

News

17 November, 2026

Onisforou plans to take legal action against council

Property developer and local businessman Theo Onisforou is planning to take legal action against Wingecarribee Shire Council for allegedly misleading police.

By Stuart Carless

Theo Onisforou looms large over Wingecarribee Shire Council. Supplied.
Theo Onisforou looms large over Wingecarribee Shire Council. Supplied.
Advertisement

Property developer and local businessman Theo Onisforou is planning to take legal action against Wingecarribee Shire Council for allegedly misleading police.

Mr Onisforou confirmed his plans on Monday after appearing in Moss Vale Local Court on charges relating to an incident at a council public forum in March.

As reported by The Southern Wire, Mr Onisforou pleaded guilty to one charge of wilfully obstructing a listed officer in the exercise of functions, but the charge was dismissed without conviction.

Two other charges – refuse or fail to comply with a direction and affix placard or paper on premises without consent – were withdrawn and dismissed.

Two Apprehended Violence Orders (AVOs) taken out by former mayor Jesse Fitzpatrick and council’s general manager Lisa Miscamble were also withdrawn and dismissed.

The charges related to an incident at the public forum before council’s March meeting, at which Mr Onisforou was refused permission to speak and was escorted from the council building by police.

Mr Onisforou said he received an offer (via his lawyer) about a week ago to plead guilty to one of the three charges in exchange for the two other charges being withdrawn and the two AVOs being reduced from 24 months to 12 months.

He said he had rejected the offer “immediately”.

Today he received an offer to plead guilty to one of the three charges in exchange for the two other charges being withdrawn and the two AVOs also being withdrawn.

Mr Onisforou said he had chosen to accept the offer because he wanted to “move on” and proceed with his own legal action against council.

“I am more interested in my future prosecution of them (council) than in their prosecution of me,” he told The Southern Wire.

Mr Onisforou said contesting the criminal charges and the two AVOs could have dragged on for months, if not years.

He is keen to proceed with his own legal action as soon as possible.

Mr Onisforou said Monday’s offer had come as no surprise.

“I’m sure the (former) mayor and the general manager did not want to be cross-examined,” he said.

Mr Onisforou also renewed claims that if he was elected to council in September 2028 – and an AVO against him was still in place – the general manager would be forced to resign.

It was a claim he made at a meeting of the Southern Highlands Community Forum earlier this year, which he believes put the general manager “on notice” of the potential consequences of a 24-month AVO.

In dismissing the one charge against Mr Onisforou without conviction, the Magistrate acknowledged that Mr Onisforou was a prominent member of the local community with an “impressive” history.

He also acknowledged Mr Onisforou’s passion for local issues – including his opposition to the proposed Repoly plastics recycling facility in Moss Vale – but said the most appropriate course of action after being refused permission to speak at the public forum would have been to leave.

He said Mr Onisforou’s offending had been at the “lower end of seriousness” without any violence or threats of violence.

He said there was no need for a sentence to deter Mr Onisforou from further offending.

Mr Onisforou said afterwards the matter should never have made it to court and described the three charges as ‘fine-only offences’.

Advertisement

“This should never have happened,” he said.

“They should have issued me with a fine.”

He believes the AVOs were another silencing tactic.

“They could never have meant it if they were happy to discontinue it,” he said.

Mr Onisforou said his allegation against the former mayor and the general manager was “misrepresentation by silence”.

He said providing false or misleading information to police (or omitting details that make it misleading) was an offence under the Crime Act.

He alleges they failed to inform police that in written correspondence he (Mr Onisforou) had asked the former mayor to “please feel free to let me know” if he was ever “impolite or unprofessional”.

The general manager was copied into that correspondence, but Mr Onisforou said neither responded.

“They never once said ‘We are unhappy with you’,” he said.

Mr Onisforou pointed to council’s own ‘Managing unreasonable conduct by complainants’ policy which states that complainants should be provided with a written warning about their conduct in the first instance unless their conduct “poses a substantial risk to the health and safety of staff and other third parties”.

He never received a letter, so was never aware his correspondence with council was considered ‘unreasonable’ – despite it being cited by police in court when they applied for the two interim AVOs.

He believes there was a vendetta against him because he criticised the former mayor for chewing gum at a council meeting and complained that Cr Fitzpatrick refused to shake his daughter’s hand at the Australia Day celebrations in Berrima when she was being recognised as a nominee for the Young Citizen of the Year award.

He said the complaint about Cr Fitzpatrick’s behaviour at the Australia Day ceremony in Berrima was dealt with internally by the general manager and dismissed.

He said none of this had been disclosed to police before the two interim AVOs were issued.

He believes the police probably felt ‘constrained’ because Cr Fitzpatrick was “the most senior public servant in the area” at the time.

Mr Onisforou – who describes himself as a “career activist against stupidity in local government” – said the court action had worked in his favour and had made him “the most popular person in the Southern Highlands”.

--------------

Subscribe to The Southern Wire Newsletter for free at the link below.

https://subscribe-forms.beehiiv.com/1986abc6-c89e-4781-9db2-cf35c9dd71e4

If you value independent local journalism across the Highlands, Tablelands and Wollondilly, please click the link below to support us to ensure we remain paywall free.

https://thesouthernwire.presspatron.com

 

Read More: Southern Highlands

Advertisement

Latest Articles

Advertisement

Most Popular

Advertisement